Balanced Literacy: The 3 Balancing Acts

What do we mean by Balanced Literacy? Before you declare that you teach in this way, check out the Lucy Calkin's Teacher College version of BL. As with any educational buzz words, not everyone is in total agreement on the components of Balanced Literacy, but everyone seems to agree on the below three balancing acts:

1. Balance between part and whole (The part is the code of reading, comprehension, & fluency, and the whole is the whole text and integrating the parts.)

2. Balance between reading to, with, and by students

3. Balance in group size (There is a bit of whole group, but most of a Balanced Literacy's teacher instruction takes place in small group or one-on-one/one-on-two.)

Whole; reading by; one-on-one

(when he gets his turn conferring with teacher)

The name of the game is to keep those balancing acts in check. Guard against too much whole group, too much focus on the mechanical part of reading (or not enough), a lack of independent reading... and on and on. It's not easy. But it's OK to plan a balanced week, instead of a balanced day. While we do, of course, want each day to have a mix of part and whole, different sizes of groups, and reading to with and by, not every day can fit it all. So if you have to skip shared reading one day in order to fit a longer read aloud, just make up for it another day.

Columbia University's Teacher's College defines the components of Balanced Literacy as: Reader's Workshop, Writer's Workshop, Small Group work, Shared Reading, Read Aloud, Word Study, and Interactive or Shared Write.

Each of those components corresponds to either part or whole teaching, both being necessary.

Reader's and Writer's Workshop are whole.
Read aloud, word study, interactive writing focus on the parts.
Shared Reading, Small Group work, and Shared Write can be whole OR part.

Yup- it's all one big, balancing act! Are you up to it?

Comments

Guided Reading Vs. Strategy Group

Chances are you've heard both terms. You may be tempted to toss guided reading and embrace the newest "most hip" reading group on the block. But hold your horses- there's room for both in a balanced literacy classroom. Here's some of the main differences: Guided Reading Group Strategy Group Teacher acts like a coach on game day, first setting the group up for the game to come, and then offering words of advice from the sidelines as the players tackle the job of reading the text beginning to end. Teacher acts like a coach during a practice, stating a discreet skill she notices the group needs to work on, teaching it, modeling it, then allowing time for practice of that skill. Teacher is like a safety net under a tightrope walker. She stays with student from the beginning to the end of the experience and coaches the whole time. Teacher teaches just one skill in isolation to tightrope walker and stud...

More on Mini's: Skills and Strategies

Imagine that in your second life, you decide to learn how to walk a tightrope. Your mentor coaches you by saying, "balance." If that was the extent of their teaching, I'd advise you to run for the hills! Balancing is a skill. But there are plenty of strategies that go into learning how to balance. Balance by holding your arms straight out. Balance by keeping your chin up. Balance by tightening your core. Teaching reading and writing are the same. Every teaching point in a minilesson needs to have both a skill and a strategy. A skill is something that you teach children because they need it to become proficient readers, and a strategy is a way to achieve it. One skill might have many different strategies, but we only teach one at a time. Even though we may call determining importance a strategy when we are talking to children, it's really a big umbrella skill. There are many different ways that a reader can determine importance. They can determine impor...

"In his listening, his heart opened wide and wider still."

“And so.” “And so what?” said Abilene. “What happened then?” No matter the personality of my class on a given year, the bittersweet story of The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane always weaves itself tightly into the fabric of our literate community. The book has this absolutely magical ability to transform a group of children who begin with an “every child for himself” stance to one who is ever so slightly more thoughtful about the position of another. It's the one book all year that I never want to end (and neither do the kids!). We read and reread. One year, I lost count of how many times we reread Chapter 4. When the music of the words surrounds us, all arguments and off-task behaviors are suspended. (Can you blame me, then, for wanting it to never end?) Wisely, even 2nd graders can see past the simple journey motif that works as a container for the deeper story, or inside story, as we refer to it. They realize that with each change Edward undergoes...

the PaperWings

Search This Blog